Pennsylvania Food Merchants Association
Join
Menu
  • About Us
    • Become A Member >
      • Retail Membership
      • Associate Membership
    • Corporate Leadership Sponsors
    • Board of Directors
    • Contact Us >
      • Staff Directory
      • Directions
      • Lodging Information
    • Antitrust Statement
    • Partner Organizations
    • Work at PFMA
    • Members Only Login
  • Government Relations
    • Advocacy >
      • 2020 Pennsylvania Priorities
      • 2020 Federal Legislative Priorities
      • Philadelphia Issues
      • Pittsburgh Issues
      • 2019 Legislative Summary
      • Visiting the Capitol
    • Committees
    • GR Team
    • FoodPAC >
      • Contribute to FoodPAC
    • Resources/Training >
      • Member Resources
      • Emergency Planning >
        • COVID-19
      • Ramp Training
      • A Bag's Life
      • Helpful Links
  • News and Publications
    • Annual Reports
    • Spectrum Newsletter
    • Year-end Reports
    • News Releases
    • PFMA in the News
    • News Archive
    • Weather Alerts
    • Media Contacts
    • Vacation Scheduler
  • Events Calendar
    • 2021 Fall Conference
    • 2021 Annual Conference
  • Services
    • Retail Coupon Processing >
      • Program Highlights
      • How To Get Started
      • Request Information
      • Dealing with Mfg Deductions
      • Sample Coupon Policy
      • Counterfeit Coupon Alert
    • Retail Price Accuracy >
      • SCP Board of Advisors
      • Inspections
      • Publications
      • Request Information
      • Related Links
    • Endorsed Services
  • Ridge Scholarship
    • Ridge Scholarship Application
    • Ridge Scholars >
      • 2019 Ridge Scholars
      • 2018 Ridge Scholars
    • Contribute / Start a Scholarship

Court Ruling Validates Beverage Tax

12/21/2016

0 Comments

 
Gary Glazer ruled in December that the tax on sweetened beverages in Philadelphia can stand, dismissing the legal challenge in its entirety. This paves the way for official enactment of the tax beginning January 1, 2017. Several local retailers, as well as PFMA, filed suit challenging the tax.

The challenge revolved around three different factors. In his ruling, Judge Glazer wrote the following:

• The tax is not duplicative with the state sales tax. Pennsylvania law prohibits localities from adding taxes that are already assessed by the state without the state’s statutory permission. In the eyes of the court, as the beverage tax is assessed to distributors and not customers, this challenge does not apply. In his ruling, Judge Glazer wrote, "The respective taxes apply to two different transactions, have two different measures and are paid by different taxpayers." 

• The tax is not preempted by SNAP. The Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) prohibits SNAP benefits to pay a sales tax. As above, the court ruled that the beverage tax is not a sales tax, but assessed upon distributors. "The tax is not collected upon ‘purchases’ at ‘retail’ made with food stamps, but only upon non-retail, distributor-level transactions."
​

• The tax does not violate the Uniformity Clause of the Pennsylvania Constitution. The Pennsylvania Constitution requires that all taxation for similar products or classes be applied in the same manner. According to the judge’s ruling, two of the four classes listed by the plaintiffs, retailers and consumers, are not subject to the tax. “The (beverage tax’s) manner and measure of calculating the tax is uniformly applied to distributors… As such, all distributors are subject to the same tax calculation formula and therefore no disparate treatment exists within the distributor class in regard to the formula and rate of tax.”
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    RSS Feed

The Pennsylvania Food Merchants Association. All Rights Reserved. © 2018
1029 Mumma Road, Wormleysburg, PA 17043
Phone: (717) 731-0600 • Toll-Free (800) 543-8207
Email: pfma@pfma.net
Website by WebLink International
MemberClicks | Member Management Software